Bethany Life

    212 Lafayette Ave, Story City, IA, 50248
    4.2 · 69 reviews
    • Independent living
    • Assisted living
    • Memory care
    • Skilled nursing
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    3.0

    Homey environment but staffing concerns

    I had a loved one at Bethany Manor and appreciated the home-like, non-institutional feel - clean, recently remodeled, apartment-style small communities, warm chapel, comfy common rooms, good food and a memory unit with therapy and on-site medical services. Many staff were genuinely kind and attentive (Lisa, Jerry, Chambre and CNA Chantel were memorable) and therapy helped during one stay. That said, staffing instability and short-staffed, overworked CNAs led to long call-light waits, at least one rude aide, spotty communication and uneven care. If atmosphere and caring people matter most, it's worth a look; if consistent staffing and reliable clinical care are your priority, be cautious.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    Healthcare services

    • Activities of daily living assistance
    • Assistance with bathing
    • Assistance with dressing
    • Assistance with transfers
    • Medication management
    • Mental wellness program

    Healthcare staffing

    • 12-16 hour nursing
    • 24-hour call system
    • 24-hour supervision

    Meals and dining

    • Diabetes diet
    • Meal preparation and service
    • Restaurant-style dining
    • Special dietary restrictions

    Room

    • Air-conditioning
    • Cable
    • Fully furnished
    • Housekeeping and linen services
    • Kitchenettes
    • Private bathrooms
    • Telephone
    • Wifi

    Memory care community services

    • Mild cognitive impairment
    • Specialized memory care programming

    Transportation

    • Community operated transportation
    • Transportation arrangement
    • Transportation arrangement (non-medical)

    Common areas

    • Beauty salon
    • Computer center
    • Dining room
    • Fitness room
    • Gaming room
    • Garden
    • Outdoor space
    • Small library
    • Wellness center

    Community services

    • Concierge services
    • Fitness programs
    • Move-in coordination

    Activities

    • Community-sponsored activities
    • Planned day trips
    • Resident-run activities
    • Scheduled daily activities

    4.20 · 69 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      3.8
    • Staff

      3.9
    • Meals

      4.0
    • Amenities

      3.8
    • Value

      4.2

    Pros

    • Caring and friendly staff
    • Several staff members named and praised (Lisa, Jerry, Chambre, Chantel)
    • Attentive nurses and CNAs
    • Home-like, non-institutional atmosphere
    • Apartment-like layout organized into small homes/communities
    • Memory unit dedicated to dementia care
    • Good made-to-order food
    • On-site bistro and comfortable seating areas
    • On-site physical and occupational therapy rooms
    • Effective therapy reported during at least one stay
    • Dietitians and swallowing assessments available
    • Nurse practitioner on-site who can prescribe medications
    • On-site bloodwork and lab testing
    • Medicaid accepted
    • Recent remodels and some brand-new building options
    • Generally clean and well-maintained facility
    • Intimate dining per house
    • Chapel and regular church services
    • Family involvement supported
    • Organized, open common areas and homey decor

    Cons

    • Short-staffed / staffing instability / use of agency staff
    • Long call-light and assistance wait times (reports up to 45 minutes)
    • Poor communication from staff and management
    • Restricted access to board members
    • Difficulty obtaining patient information for medical POA
    • No electronic record keeping reported
    • Perception that doctor visits are discouraged
    • Mixed or inconsistent therapy effectiveness
    • Very few activities; residents reported boredom
    • Some CNAs reported as rude or unkind
    • Downsizing of staff and services
    • Older building sections with small rooms and ongoing renovations
    • Small dining areas in older units
    • Overworked CNAs and rough staffing periods
    • Reports of bad resident outcomes attributed by some to staffing
    • Chaplain not being a pastor (possible expectation mismatch)
    • Mixed overall care experience across stays
    • Long waits and difficulty getting timely information

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across reviews is mixed but leans positive around the personal warmth, atmosphere, and certain clinical resources, while showing consistent concerns about staffing, communication, and activity levels. Many reviewers emphasize that the facility feels home-like rather than institutional: Bethany Life is described as organized into small homes or communities, with intimate dining per house, comfortable seating, a bistro, and a warm chapel. Several people praise the cleanliness, recent remodels, and in some instances brand-new building sections and large rooms. The environment and decor (antique hallway touches, family-friendly spaces) contribute to a welcoming, Christian-oriented setting that many families and residents find comforting.

    Staff quality is one of the clearest strengths and also a source of variable experiences. Numerous reviewers name and praise individual staff members (Lisa, Jerry, Chambre, Chantel) and describe nurses and CNAs as caring, attentive, and respectful. Some reviewers explicitly state that residents were well cared for and that staff greeted residents by name and supported family involvement and church attendance. Therapy and clinical resources are notable positives in many reviews: on-site physical therapy rooms, dietitians, swallowing assessments, a nurse practitioner who can prescribe medications, and on-site lab/bloodwork services receive praise. One reviewer specifically noted effective therapy during a first stay and professional therapy teams that helped recovery.

    Despite those strengths, there are repeated and significant operational concerns. Staffing is the most frequently mentioned problem: reports of short-staffing, use of agency staff, downsizing, and overworked CNAs recur across reviews. These staffing issues are linked in reviewers' comments to long call-light response times (one review cites waits up to 45 minutes), long waits for patient assistance, and in a few cases, perceived poor resident outcomes. Reviewers also report inconsistency — where some stays are described as excellent, others are characterized by rough patches and substandard care. The presence of at least one CNA described as mean and some accounts of insufficient assistance overnight (a midnight shower request example) underscore variability in day-to-day experience.

    Communication and administrative accessibility are also important negative themes. Multiple reviewers note poor communication from staff and management, difficulties obtaining timely information about residents (especially when a family member holds medical power of attorney), restricted access to board members, and an absence of electronic record keeping — all of which contribute to family frustration. A less common but notable complaint is that doctor visits are discouraged, which could be a concern for families expecting proactive medical oversight. These administrative shortcomings, combined with staffing fluctuations, are likely drivers of the inconsistent experiences reported by families.

    Programming and activity levels receive critical attention as well. Several reviewers describe very few activities and bored residents, which contrasts with the active-therapy and exercise resources advertised. While physical therapy and exercise options exist on-site, everyday social and engagement programming appears limited according to some reviewers. For families evaluating Bethany Life for long-term residence, this difference between clinical therapy resources and daily activity offerings is important to consider.

    Facility differences are also relevant: reviews reference both a brand-new building and older sections undergoing renovations. Positives associated with the newer spaces include larger rooms, modern finishes, and organized small communities; older areas reportedly have smaller double rooms and smaller dining spaces until renovations are complete. Practical positives include acceptance of Medicaid and being on a waiting list for some families, which may be important for financial planning.

    In summary, Bethany Life shows clear strengths in staff compassion (though uneven), a home-like environment, specific clinical resources (therapy, NP, dietitians, labs), and clean, recently remodeled spaces in parts of the campus. However, recurring concerns around staffing levels and stability, long response times to call lights and assistance, inconsistent therapy outcomes across stays, limited day-to-day activities, and gaps in communication and record-keeping are substantial and repeatedly cited. Prospective residents and families should weigh the highly positive accounts of caring staff and good facilities against the operational warnings about staffing and communication. Visiting multiple times, asking targeted questions about staffing ratios, activity schedules, electronic records, and procedures for medical visits and POA information access, and requesting references from families with recent stays would help clarify whether current conditions match the positive or negative patterns described in these reviews.

    Location

    Map showing location of Bethany Life

    About Bethany Life

    Bethany Life sits at 212 Lafayette Ave in Story City, Iowa, and has served older adults since 1914, started by regional Lutheran, Methodist, and Catholic churches, and you'll find they offer a broad mix of services and housing, so folks in all stages of aging can get the support they need, and what makes it stand out is their life care at home model, the only one in Iowa, which means people can get care while staying in their own house, through Bethany at Home, while others might choose to live in one of their Twin Homes, Cedar Place apartments for affordable independent living, or with assisted living and independent living at Timberland Village, and the community's got a focus on helping residents live as independently as possible, though they're ready with skilled care, therapy services, and things like LifeBridge Transitional Care for when someone needs help after a hospital stay, and they've expanded over the years to include memory care units for folks with more progressed dementia, with staff trained for Alzheimer's and memory care, and they've got chaplaincy services, so people can join Bible studies, prayer services, and counseling, and there's always something happening with the activities department, whether it's entertainment, socializing, or group projects, plus residents get daily living help like bathing, dressing, feeding, and medication, and you'll notice amenities like the Tom and Stevie Bistro, an on-site spa, and different programs meant to support wellbeing and comfort, and with their range of options-assisted living, skilled nursing, memory care, long-term care, therapy, respite care-they try to make transitions between care levels easier, and their Bethany Life Foundation supports community giving, so over time, they keep adding to what they offer, always working to match services to people's needs, with a care finder tool and a website if someone wants to look up more information, and you can tell they've built a place where people can stay connected and cared for, with options that aren't always found other places in Iowa.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story residential building with balconies and a tower-like structure at one corner, surrounded by landscaped greenery and walkways with people walking and sitting nearby during dusk.
      $7,071 – $9,192+3.6 (26)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Marvella

      825 Mount Curve Blvd, St. Paul, MN, 55116
    • Front exterior view of Harmony Gardens Senior Living facility showing a large, multi-section building with multiple windows, a covered entrance with an American flag in front, and a parking lot with several cars parked.
      Pricing on request4.4 (30)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Harmony Gardens Senior Living

      1438 County Rd C E, Maplewood, MN, 55109
    • Front exterior view of the American House Town and Country senior living facility with a circular driveway, landscaped greenery, and an American flag on a flagpole under a wooden entrance canopy.
      $5,000+3.9 (61)
      suite
      assisted living, memory care

      American House Town and Country

      1020 Woods Mill Rd, Town and Country, MO, 63017
    • Exterior view of a large, modern three-story senior living facility building with a covered entrance driveway, surrounded by green lawns and trees under a partly cloudy blue sky.
      $5,633 – $7,322+3.9 (69)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      Alto Grayslake

      1865 E Belvidere Rd, Grayslake, IL, 60030
    • Exterior view of Belmont Village Senior Living Glenview building at dusk, showing a large covered entrance with white columns, well-maintained landscaping with bushes and trees, and a multi-story brick and siding facade with lit windows.
      $3,965+4.6 (121)
      Semi-private
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Glenview

      2200 Golf Rd, Glenview, IL, 60025
    • Evening view of the entrance area of Belmont Village Senior Living Lincoln Park, featuring brick walls, decorative lighting fixtures, a circular chandelier on the ceiling, and a sign with the facility's name visible near the street.
      $5,506 – $7,157+4.5 (131)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Lincoln Park

      700 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL, 60614

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    7 facilities$4,665/mo
    7 facilities$4,665/mo
    20 facilities$4,501/mo
    0 facilities
    27 facilities$4,420/mo
    2 facilities
    6 facilities$5,860/mo
    0 facilities
    0 facilities
    14 facilities$4,471/mo
    0 facilities
    © 2025 Mirador Living